Medicare Advantage vs Original Medicare Calculator
Compare costs and coverage to find your best Medicare option.
Original Medicare Costs
Part A Premium:$ 0 (usually free)
Part B Premium:$ 174.70/mo
Part B Deductible:$ 240
Medigap Plan G:$ 150/mo
Part D Drug Plan:$ 30/mo
Estimated Annual Cost:$ 4496
Original Medicare = Part A + Part B + Medigap (optional) + Part D (optional).
Medicare Advantage Costs
MA Premium:$ 18/mo
MA Deductible:$ 200
Max Out-of-Pocket:$ 4500
Drug Coverage:Included
Estimated Annual:$ 1766
Medicare Advantage bundles Part A, B, and usually D with max out-of-pocket protection.
Doctor & Network Flexibility
Original Medicare:Any Medicare-approved doctor nationwide
Medicare Advantage:Network-based (HMO/PPO), may need referrals
Original Medicare offers nationwide access. MA plans use networks (HMO/PPO).
Travel Coverage
Original Medicare:Good
Medicare Advantage:Moderate
Original Medicare works nationwide. MA covers emergencies only outside network area.
Recommendation Score
Original Medicare Score:5
Medicare Advantage Score:5
Recommended: Depends on preferences
Score based on your preferences for doctors, travel, health needs, and location.
Medicare Decision Key Points
- Original Medicare: nationwide coverage, choose any doctor, add Medigap
- Medicare Advantage: bundled coverage, max out-of-pocket, may have $0 premium
- MA includes drug coverage (Part D), Original needs separate Part D
- Original + Medigap: predictable costs, no network restrictions
- MA: lower premiums but copays, network limits, max OOP protection
- Travel frequently? Original Medicare better for nationwide access
- Prefer specific doctors? Original Medicare offers more flexibility
- Good health + urban? MA may offer extra benefits at lower cost
- Can switch during Medicare Open Enrollment (Oct 15 - Dec 7)